
CRANFORD
by Lin Coghlan and Shaun McKenna
based on the novel by Elizabeth Gaskell
co-created and directed by Josh Roche
Orange Tree Theatre, Richmond – until 16 January 2027
running time: 2 hours 15 minutes including interval
https://orangetreetheatre.co.uk/whats-on/cranford/
On the Orange Tree Theatre’s website, this stage distillation of Elizabeth Gaskell’s 1853 novel (which was also adapted into a beloved BBC TV series) is billed as a festive treat, and wow they aren’t kidding. The warmth and joy emanating from the stage in Josh Roche’s deeply lovable in-the-round production ought to be bottled and sold as an alternative to visiting the doctor.
It doesn’t hurt that it features a quintet of fabulous actresses who are no longer ingenues but are very much at the top of their tragicomic games. Plus it delivers a career-highlight role for rising star Phoebe Pryce, entrancing and emotionally engaged as the Mancunian vicar’s wife who comes to the rural parish of Cranford to escape her own woes and ends up way more invested than she ever intended to be.
One of many marvellous things about Lin Coghlan, Shaun McKenna and the aforementioned Roche’s Cranford is that it feels like an authentic play in its own right. Too often stage adaptations of novels (A Little Life, The Line of Beauty, the NT’s His Dark Materials, even the RSC’s famed Nicholas Nickleby) have stretches that are basically dead stage time but are slavishly reproduced for the theatre just because they were in the original book. Perhaps because Gaskell’s novel was essentially a series of vignettes with the characters as a through-running theme, the stage Cranford, like it’s television cousin, has a rhythm and detail that feels unforced and entirely matched to the theatre.
For much of the first half, any semblance of plot is playing second fiddle to the mood and characters. That said, when the central figures are as glorious as Sara Crowe’s low-key man-hungry Mrs Forester, Alexandra Gilbreath’s perpetually apoplectic Miss Pole, Sara Powell’s snobbish, on-her-dignity Mrs Jamieson or Abigail Cruttenden’s skilfully delineated doubling as severe spinster Deborah then warm-hearted Lady Glenmire, who’s going to complain. These women are dramatic and comic gold.
If act one is delightful and frequently hilarious, the second half is where the story and the dramatic meat really kicks in. Tamsin Greig is heartbreakingly good as kind, cautious Matty (Judi Dench on the telly, but Greig is every bit as fine) whose combination of steadfastness and unconventional thinking really drives the story. Watch Greig’s face as Matty receives news of a lost love’s death, or her brief sudden outpouring of emotion when housemaid Martha (Saffron Dey, spirited and superb) says she didn’t know what love was until she met her partner Jem (Robert Merriam, also excellent): this is beautiful, honest acting and Greig gets right to the heart of who this contained, ill-favoured but ultimately triumphant woman is. ‘Nice’ is seldom this compelling but Greig nails it. Pryce entirely matches her as a woman consumed by grief and it’s strange relationship to morality but who eventually comes good. If you don’t love these two central figures you may need to check your vital signs.
Roche’s staging, lit to perfection by Jamie Platt, moves at a terrific clip but never at the expense of clarity. The way scenes bleed into each other is an exemplar of superb direction and storytelling, as is the way an unwanted pie is passed around between the central women during a key scene….a mere prop becomes a metaphor for a multitude of relationships.
We clearly don’t live in a world where the good always get what they deserve, but it’s awfully lovely to go and spend a couple of hours in a place where some of them do. The shows ultimate message about the power of friendship and the importance of community couldn’t be more pertinent to the festive season. Go and see Cranford: it will enhance your life. Take tissues.








