ajhlovestheatre

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Blog

  • KYOTO – ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – stunning climate change drama proves as thought-provoking as it is entertaining

    Photograph by Manuel Harlan

    KYOTO

    by Joe Murphy and Joe Robertson

    directed by Stephen Daldry and Justin Martin

    @sohoplace, London – until 3 May 2025

    running time: 2 hours 50 minutes including interval

    https://nimaxtheatres.com/shows/kyoto/

    Anybody wondering if theatre can still be truly relevant needs to see Kyoto. It’s an epic full of fire and fascination, a cracking piece of entertainment with a deeply serious core. Of course, authors Joe Murphy and Joe Robertson, and their Good Chance Theatre company who are co-producing with the Royal Shakespeare Company, have form when it comes to creating theatre that breaks the normal rules of playmaking, while speaking urgently to the world we live in now. 

    Murphy and Robertson were the iconoclastic creatives behind 2018’s The Jungle, which was developed and set in the Calais refugee camp, and went on to win acclaim and prizes globally. That was a rich tapestry of humanity characterised by a searing intelligence while simultaneously wearing its heart on its sleeve, and this is similarly stirring and impressive. 

    Kyoto, centring on the historic 1997 international climate change conference which saw an unprecedented unanimity from global representatives to drastically cut carbon emissions, is a glossier affair, as thrillingly directed by Stephen Daldry and Justin Miller, but has the same grit, compassion and bravura theatricality. In a series of punchy vignettes, Murphy and Robertson dramatise the run-up to the Kyoto summit, all watched over by a Mephistophelean narrator, oil lobbyist Don Pearlman (a powerfully laconic Stephen Kunken). Facts and figures are hurled at us by actors and from video walls at rear of the playing area and all around the auditorium, yet the individuals doing the talking, while little more than sketches in some instances, resonate strongly as human beings. The command and delivery of information recalls James Graham at his most meticulous and energised, while the dynamism of the deluxe staging suggests a team of creatives at the very top of their game. 

    A terrific international cast, representing delegates from all over the world, ricochet around Miriam Buether’s imposing, all-encompassing conference room set (which features actual audience members seated at the central circular table), dextrously changing character and appearance in the blink of an eye, bringing to life a fascinating array of people, some familiar, others less so. Ferdy Roberts is a bluntly funny, sympathetic John Prescott representing the EU, and Kristin Atherton captures accurately Andrea Merckel’s unique blend of warmth and severity. Jorge Bosche is a ribald delight as Raúl Estrada-Oyuela, the Argentine diplomat who brokers the Kyoto Procotol with a mixture of bonhomie and bloody mindedness, and Nancy Crane makes a strong impression as the embattled American delegate.

    Daldry and Miller employ a flamboyant raft of theatrical techniques to flesh out this compelling story, but the focus, despite all the sound and fury, never wavers. The stagecraft on display is dazzling… this is tremendously exciting total theatre, propulsive and vital, yet the clarity and gravitas are never sacrificed to mere entertainment.

    But entertaining Kyoto most certainly is, playing out with the grip and menace of  a thriller, as the ‘Big Oil’ controllers, who fund and influence Pearlman, appear out of the murk like the Seven Sisters of the Apocalypse, accompanied by Paul Englishby’s threatening sound score. If that sinister group represents the darker forces pulling at the morally ambiguous Pearlman then his questioning, good-hearted wife (lovely performance by Jenna Augen) personifies the light. 

    It’s also frequently very funny, sometimes bleakly so, such as the sequence where Pearlman introduces delegates one by one at the conference before stating the carbon emissions caused by each individual’s international journey. The laughter catches in our collective throats though when it is revealed that the fossil fuel conglomerates have been aware of the damage to the planet since 1959 but chose to suppress the information. Remarkably, the play never descends into preachiness, but the sense of time being of the essence for this compromised planet is palpable, and the raw excitement and catharsis to the final thrashing out of the agreement is pure drama, and becomes genuinely moving.

    Whether observing from the sidelines, cynically haranguing the audience, or cracking open with rage, Kunken achieves a magnificent UK stage debut. Murphy and Robertson charge the real life figure of Pearlman with a similar jet black wit and energy as Tony Kushner found for the admittedly more openly malevolent Roy Cohn in Angels In America. The writing is caustic, muscular and literate, peppered with wit and expletives.

    The production ends on a quizzical, visually arresting note – Pearlman’s widow alone on stage as the cherry blossom dances around her – that initially feels hopeful and poetic but cools to downright chilling when you recall the Japanese diplomat’s repeated point that the blossom falls earlier every year due to alterations in the climate. This utterly brilliant show, a smash hit in Stratford-Upon-Avon last year and surely on course for further success in London and probably beyond, is a clarion call for change, for mutual understanding and collaboration, and for holding our leaders to account. It should also be on every school’s curriculum. Essential, unforgettable, and, hopefully, life-changing theatre. You have to see this.

    January 17, 2025

  • FIREBIRD – ⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Cold War love story is watchable but fails to fully ignite

    Theo Walker and Robert Eades, photograph by Geraint Lewis

    FIREBIRD

    by Richard Hough

    based on the memoir by Sergey Fetisov and the screenplay by Peeter Rebane and Tom Prior

    directed by Owen Lewis

    Kings Head Theatre, London – until 9 February 2025

    running time: 85 minutes no interval

    https://kingsheadtheatre.com/whats-on/firebird

    Based on Sergey Fetisov’s memoir and its acclaimed film adaptation, Richard Hough’s new play is a gay love story set against a background of modern history in Soviet Union-occupied Estonia in the late 1970s. Combat pilot Roman (Robert Eades) meets aspiring actor Sergey (Theo Walker) who is whiling away his Russian National Service on a Tallinn airbase, just as the Soviets join the war in the Middle East, heightening Cold War tensions. Owen Lewis’s production is peppered with recordings of Brezhnev’s speeches at the time, conveniently translated into excitable English.

    Firebird as a script has a surprising amount of humour, given its setting and themes, and is gripping enough that you seldom notice how uncomfortable the seating in the Kings Head’s main house is. There’s also an unadorned brevity that doesn’t fully do justice to a story that should be more gut-wrenching than it appears here. It’s hard to know if it’s the acting or the writing, but the urgency of feeling between the two men doesn’t really come across, and they go from illicit kisses to full-on co-habiting in just a few pages of script, rather as though crucial scenes for the storytelling were somehow jettisoned or lost during the creative process, an impression further reinforced as the play continues. The tragedy that engulfs the principal characters doesn’t sear as one hopes it might. 

    Eades is all chiselled physical perfection as the man devoted to his flying career until love derails that (somewhat) but is a bit stilted in his delivery of the dialogue, while Walker brings a boyish self-possession to the more emotionally available Sergey. Apart from some snogging and teasing removal of shirts, the connection between the men seems unhelpfully tepid: there’s very little chemistry.

    Intriguingly, the heterosexuals fare much better in this play. Nigel Hastings delivers a compelling, multi-layered account of Colonel Kuznetsov, a high ranking air force official who may just understand more than he lets on. Hastings convincingly conveys the humanity beneath the starched authoritarianism in a beautifully modulated performance. Even more fascinating is Sorcha Kennedy, marvellous as Luisa, the Estonian clerical worker who befriends Roman and Sergey before becoming unwittingly embroiled in their personal lives. Kennedy invests this good-hearted young woman with irrepressible warmth and sass, but also an endearing vulnerability. There’s a moment where the penny drops about the true nature of Luisa’s best friends‘s relationship and Kennedy plays it exquisitely. There’s a Rattigan-esque wistfulness and delicacy to a scene where Luisa meets with her former boss Kuznetsov over tea and confesses to her isolation and depression in the wake of an unwise marriage, and a rueful final scene between Luisa and Sergey is beautifully, heartbreakingly well done.

    Lewis’s staging is strong on atmosphere thanks to Gregor Donnelly’s suitably grim period setting and a striking lighting design by Clancy Flynn. It’s also heavy on music and sound effects (nice work by Jac Cooper) although the lengthy scene transitions have a tendency to interrupt the storytelling flow. 

    Altogether this is an agreeable ninety minutes but it doesn’t hit as hard as it should. There doesn’t feel that there is as much at stake as there should be, but it’s a highly watchable insight into a recent period of modern history, lent an added piquancy by the fact that it’s true story.

    January 15, 2025

  • TITANIQUE – ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Céline Dion takes on the iceberg and wins in this fun-filled comedy musical

    Photograph by Mark Senior

    TITANIQUE 

    co-authored by Marla Mindelle, Constantine Rousouli and Tye Blue

    directed by Tye Blue

    Criterion Theatre, London – booking to 8 June 2025

    running time: 1 hour 50 minutes no interval

    https://london.titaniquemusical.com

    Musical theatre doesn’t get much crazier than this. Titanique, the off-Broadway sleeper hit that marries the Céline Dion songbook to a jawdroppingly irreverent replay of the James Cameron blockbuster movie about the infamous passenger ship disaster, has docked in the West End amid much hilarity and mayhem. Tye Blue (who also directs), Marla Mindelle and Constantine Rousouli (who respectively played Céline and Jack originally but sadly don’t repeat their performing work for London) have created a caffeinated campfest loaded with pop culture references, anachronisms, visual jokes and banging tunes. It doesn’t take itself remotely seriously and anybody turning up thinking this is a revival of the classy Maury Yeston-Peter Stone tuner Titanic is in for one hell of a shock. 

    The show’s premise is that the divine Dion, interrupting a tour of the Titanic museum while dressed as a bag lady, was actually ON the ill-fated ocean liner and is keen to share her recollections, all while screlting in sequins of course. Blue, Mindelle and Rousouli adopt an attitude to the original story and their reinterpretation of it that might most accurately be described as scattershot. One of the ships mates is dressed as one of the Mario Brothers and named Luigi because, well, that’s what he looks like, a power-belting Molly Brown (Charlotte Wakefield, fabulous if a trifle youthful) is repeatedly referred to as Kathy Bates because that’s who played her in the film, and one of the movie’s other stars Victor Garber (gleeful Darren Bennett) is similarly commemorated. Meanwhile heroine Rose’s villainous fiancé Cal (Jordan Luke Gage, all hilarious snarls and pouts, with a roof-scraping vocal belt) has a face full of make up and a Grindr profile, and her scheming Mum is played by a man in an alice band with pigeons stuck to it (gorgeously scenery-chewing Stephen Guarino, imported from the American production) ….and wait til you see how they do the iceberg.

    There’s audience interaction, lip synching à la Drag Race, a couple of improvisation sequences that don’t land as well here as they did in the New York original, a life size cardboard cutout of Patti LuPone gets bandied about for no very intelligible reason, and some ‘British-isms’ have been inserted (including references to The Traitors and Eastenders) for London. It’s tremendous fun, revelling simultaneously in its own ridiculousness and in the portentous seriousness of the film, even if Blue’s rumbustious staging still feels better suited to the basement comedy venue in Manhattan’s Chelsea district where it originated, than to a grand proscenium arch theatre. In that more modest setting, it was slightly less obvious that there are a couple of sections where the humour gets self-indulgent to the point of temporarily losing its audience or that the central romantic couple have one or two too many jokey duets.

    These are comparatively small quibbles though in a piece of joyful theatrical frippery that knows exactly what it is and who it’s aimed at. Perhaps surprisingly for a show aimed so squarely at the funny bone, the musical aspect is stunning. Nicholas James Connell’s orchestrations and arrangements are fresh and vital, and played by a band that’s tighter than the sailors uniforms in those homoerotic Jean-Paul Gaultier perfume TV ads. The vocals are uniformly wonderful, and there are frequent moments where the company is singing en masse that take the breath away. Ellenore Scott’s choreography finds the sweet spot between slickness and the scrappy, off-the-wall quality that distinguishes Titanique from more conventional musicals.

    A charismatic Lauren Drew sings up a storm and captures Céline’s unique combination of diva bravado and childlike enthusiasm but hasn’t, as yet, found the warmth, authority or sheer lunacy that made Mindelle’s original creation so memorable. The performance of the night comes from newcomer Kat Ronney as the much maligned Rose: a brilliant physical comedienne with a sensational, versatile voice, she unerringly locates the middle ground between sincerity and bonkers that drives this outlandish show, and she even looks a bit like Kate Winslet in the film. Opposite her, Rob Houchen isn’t perhaps a natural clown but has charming, athletic presence and terrific vocals. Layton Williams plays a couple of roles as, er, Layton Williams mostly but is great value. 

    Ultimately, this is an almost aggressively feel-good night out. Yes, it’s a little baggy and messy, and worked better in a less glossy iteration and an unconventional performance space, but it’s more exhilarating than exhausting (just), the affection for La Dion is unmistakable and the camp joy generated is enough to power a dozen cruise ships. “My heart will go on” proclaim the lyrics of Titanic’s signature tune, a major hit for Céline Dion and here given the inevitable audience singalong treatment, and so, I suspect, will Titanique.

    January 13, 2025

  • THE TOP 20 NEW SHOWS FOR 2025 I’M MOST LOOKING FORWARD TO

    Boop!, Real Women Have Curves, La Cage Aux Folles, Scissorhandz, Alterations, Smash, Intimate Apparel, Cry-Baby, Unicorn, Here We Are, Punch, The Frogs (all images supplied by productions)

    (In alphabetical but not necessarily preferential order)

    *

    1. ALTERATIONS – National/Lyttelton Theatre, London – 20 February to 25 April

    https://www.nationaltheatre.org.uk/productions/alterations/

    1970s London seen through the eyes of the Windrush generation in Michael Abbensett’s poignant comedy, directed by Lynette Linton whose characteristic attention to detail and ability to coalesce comic and tragic should perfectly match this kind of material. Cast includes Arinzé Kene.

    *

    2. BOOP! – Broadhurst Theatre, New York City – open-ended run from 11 March

    https://boopthemusical.com

    This went down a storm during its Chicago premiere and now David Foster, Bob Martin and Susan Birkenhead’s big band, big budget, big hearted distillation of the beloved cartoon icon heads for New York, staged by Jerry Mitchell. Newcomer Jasmine Amy Rogers looks like a total star as Betty and Tony winner Faith Prince is in the cast. 

    *

    3. CLUELESS – Trafalgar Theatre, London – open-ended run from 15 February

    https://cluelessonstage.com


    The delightful movie transplanted Jane Austen’s Emma to the gossipy, image-obsessed world of American High School, and comes to the stage in an eagerly awaited new tuner with a score by KT Tunstall. Move over Elle and Regina, here comes Cher. This should be a lot of fun. 

    *

    4. CRY-BABY – Arcola Theatre, London – 3 March to 12 April

    https://www.arcolatheatre.com/whats-on/cry-baby-the-musical/

    Hairspray proved that John Waters movies are an inspired basis for stage musicals, and although this one flopped on Broadway, the score is a jazzy, boppy gem. Plus any musical at the intimate Arcola is a special experience. 

    *

    5. EVITA – London Palladium, London – 14 June to 6 September

    https://www.evitathemusical.com

    Arguably Andrew Lloyd Webber’s greatest score, with Tim Rice’s dazzling lyrics, this thrilling rock opera returns. Jamie Lloyd’s earlier version for Regents Park was an astonishing deconstruction and it will be fascinating to see how his vision translates to the Palladium stage. 

    *

    6. FOLLIES – Grand Opera House, Belfast – 13 to 20 September

    https://niopera.com/performances/follies/

    Northern Ireland Opera and their AD Cameron Menzies gave us an intelligent, enjoyable Into The Woods a couple of years ago. Now they move on to this most epic of Sondheims, a masterpiece of yearning, nostalgia and exquisitely elegant bitterness, all filtered through the maestro’s take on the Great American Songbook. 

    *

    7. HAMLET – Royal Shakespeare Theatre, Stratford-Upon-Avon – 8 February to 29 March

    https://www.rsc.org.uk/hamlet/

    Rising star Luke Thallon is the latest Prince of Denmark in the Royal Shakespeare Company’s new production, helmed by the endlessly inventive Rupert Goold. Nancy Carroll, one of my favourite actresses, takes on Gertrude. 

    *

    8. HERE WE ARE – National/Lyttelton Theatre, London – 23 April to 28 June

    https://www.nationaltheatre.org.uk/productions/here-we-are/

    The final Sondheim: already seen in New York and inspired by two Buñuel films, this powerful, unsettling but playful piece is directed by Joe (Wicked) Mantello and has a magnificent cast including Tracie Bennett, Jane Krakowski, Martha Plimpton, Jesse Tyler Ferguson and Denis O’Hare. 

    *

    9. INTIMATE APPAREL – Donmar Warehouse, London – 20 June to 9 August

    https://www.donmarwarehouse.com/whats-on/34/by-lynn-nottage/intimate-apparel


    Pulitzer Prize winning Lynn Nottage is one of the greatest living American playwrights so this lyrical 2003 piece, last seen here over a decade ago, will be a must-see, especially as Nottage’s inspired long term collaborator Lynette Linton directs. The production also marks the London stage return of acclaimed American actress Samira Wiley. 

    *

    10. KYOTO – @sohoplace, London – 9 January to 3 May

    https://sohoplace.org/shows/kyoto

    Eagerly awaited West End transfer for Joe Murphy and Joe Robertson’s much lauded climate change drama. A triumphant popular and critical hit for the RSC, this is a major theatrical event.

    *

    11. LA CAGE AUX FOLLES – Theatre du Châtelet, Paris – 5 December to 10 January 2026

    https://www.chatelet.com/programmation/25-26/la-cage-aux-folles/

    Acclaimed French screen and stage star Laurent Lafitte leads as Alvin/Zaza in a brand new production of Jerry Herman and Harvey Fierstein’s joyful, heartfelt Broadway extravaganza at this most opulent and atmospheric of Parisian venues. 

    *

    12. MURIEL’S WEDDING – Curve Theatre, Leicester – 10 April to 10 May

    https://www.curveonline.co.uk/whats-on/shows/muriels-wedding/

    Already a smash hit in Sydney, this stage musical version of the beloved cult movie arrives in the UK with Simon Phillips and Andrew Hallsworth (director and choreographer of Priscilla on stage) reprising their original work. The score is a mix of original songs and ABBA classics. 

    *

    13. PUNCH – Young Vic, London – 1 March to 26 April

    https://www.youngvic.org/whats-on/punch

    Any new James Graham play is an event, and this was hugely well received in its Nottingham premiere. Exploring the seismic consequences on a youngster’s life of an ill-considered one off punch, Adam Penford’s production features the glorious Julie Hesmondhalgh.

    *

    14. PURPOSE – Hayes Theatre, NYC – 25 February to 6 July

    https://purposeonbroadway.com

    Phylicia Rashad directs the new play from one of America’s most exciting writers Branden (Appropriate, An Octoroon, The Comeuppance) Jacob-Jenkins. This family drama originated at Chicago’s Steppenwolf Theatre, and the Broadway company includes LaTanya Richardson Jackson and Tony winner Kara Young. 

    *

    15. REAL WOMEN HAVE CURVES – James Earl Jones Theatre, NYC – open/ended run from 1 April

    https://realwomenhavecurvesbroadway.com

    With its themes of strong fabulous women, immigration and pursuing your dreams, this musicalisation of the landmark indie film could hardly be more timely. The Boston ART premiere last year was raved about, and Joy Huerta and Benjamin Velez’s Latin-flavoured score is entrancing.

    *

    16. SCISSORHANDZ – Southwark Playhouse/Elephant, London – 23 January to 29 March

    https://southwarkplayhouse.co.uk/productions/scissorhandz/

    With a starry team of producers including Michelle Visage and Lance Bass, this celebration of the adored Tim Burton movie about the macabre but gentle misfit is packed with pop hits, and looks set to become a real fan favourite.

    *

    17. SING STREET – Lyric Hammersmith Theatre, London – 8 July to 23 August

    https://lyric.co.uk/shows/sing-street/

    This 1980s Dublin-set tale of the thrill of young love and the transformative power of music, based on the film and with a score full of bangers, had its planned Broadway debut scuppered by the pandemic, but here it is in London. This sounds like a real winner (and good luck with getting ‘Drive It Like You Stole It’ out of your head once you’ve heard it).

    *

    18. SMASH – Imperial Theatre, NYC – open-ended run from 11 March

    https://smashbroadway.com

    The TV series was every Broadway lover’s dream and now here comes the ACTUAL Broadway musical about the show-within-a-show. The pedigree is fabulous: score by the Hairspray creators, staging by Tony winner Susan Stroman and a cast featuring some of the main stem’s finest including Robyn Hurder, Brooks Ashmanksas, Krysta Rodriguez and Kristen Nielsen.

    *

    19. THE FROGS – Southwark Playhouse/Borough – 23 May to 28 June

    https://southwarkplayhouse.co.uk/productions/the-frogs/

    Another Sondheim and I make no apology for that! This seldom seen early gem, inspired by an Aristophanes comedy, is a musical satire cum fantasy cum road trip story that asks “can art save civilisation?” Glee’s Kevin McHale makes his UK stage debut.

    *

    20. UNICORN – Garrick Theatre, London – 4 February to 26 April

    https://www.unicorntheplay.co.uk

    New plays premiering in the West End are an increasingly rare thing, but then Mike (Cock, King Charles III) Bartlett is a pretty uncommon playwright. James Macdonald directs a dream team of Nicola Walker, Erin Doherty and Stephen Mangan in this provocative look at polyamory.



    December 29, 2024

  • MY TOP 20 NEW THEATRE SHOWS OF 2024

    Another year of seeing theatre, much of it fabulous, some of it so-so and a couple of absolute disasters (which I’m not going to go into here, but would be happy to talk about in person….)

    A special mention to The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, which isn’t on this years list as its earlier incarnation at Southwark Playhouse was on last year’s, but it’s a joy and a thrill to now see it ensconced at the Ambassadors as a fully fledged West End hit. If you haven’t seen it yet, do go….it’s the best new British musical in decades.

    Other British musicals I adored this year, but didn’t quite make it to my top ten, were the Old Vic’s surprisingly moving Live Aid nostalgia fest Just For One Day (transferring to the West End’s Shaftesbury next spring), and Babies, a pop-driven musical comedy about teens pretending to parent dolls for a school project, that punched well above its weight.

    There was the grand Palladium revival of Hello, Dolly! with Imelda Staunton and an outstanding cast, which was on a scale we seldom see these days, and West End and Broadway smashes & Juliet and Come From Away headed out on UK tour with new casts every bit the equal of (and in a couple of instances, superior to) their predecessors. Billy Crudup made an accomplished London debut in the off-Broadway import, solo Harry Clarke which was a dazzling example of simple but essential storytelling.

    As of Shakespeare, the Globe gave us a rapturous Much Ado About Nothing which felt almost radical thanks to its adherence to Elizabethan dress (seldom seen these days!) but truly fresh in its unusually complex but entirely delightful new take on Beatrice and Benedick (Amalia Vitale and Ekow Quartey, both irresistible). Then the National’s monumental, African-tinged Coriolanus was an autumn highlight.

    The National also gave us a searing modern take on Antigone, with Alexander Zeldin’s The Other Place featuring an incandescent Emma D’Arcy, and the life-enhancing American play The Hot Wing King by Katori Hall. Another glorious piece of writing from a female African American writer was the Donmar’s Skeleton Crew, Dominique Morisseau’s engrossing, humane Rust Belt drama, featuring an astonishing cast.

    In West London, the Finborough had another strong year with a triumphant rediscovery of Sidney Howard’s American family drama The Silver Cord in a flawless revival and Foam, Henry McDonald’s intense, fact-based examination of far right politics versus gay identity leading their list of must-sees, or rather, should-have-seens if you didn’t. Just a mile or so away, the Bush’s riveting, satisfying My Father’s Fable proved that rising star Faith Omole is as fine a writer as she is an actor. For me, the jewel in the Lyric Hammersmith’s 2024 crown was a world class revival of Brian Friel’s Faith Healer, dominated by a laser- sharp, unforgettable Justine Mitchell.

    Further afield, the Rose in Kingston and Northampton Theatres collaborated on a fine, unsettling stage version of Kazuo Ishiguro’s Never Let Me Go, and while everyone’s talking about the National’s outrageous, technicolour Importance of Being Earnest, for me the wildest Wilde of the year was the Manchester Royal Exchange’s joyous but thoughtful update which saw Cecily as a TikTok-er, a Trustafarian Jack, and Lady Bracknell as a briskly brutal Home Counties matron in Barbour jacket and pearls.

    I’ll never forget the enchanting new Broadway sleeper hit Maybe Happy Ending with Darren Criss and newcomer Helen J Shen breaking hearts as a couple of failing robots dealing with some very human problems. There was a great deal of robust fun, as well as lashings of blood plus legs crossed in discomfort, at off-Broadway’s Teeth, a rollicking rock musical based on a notorious gorefest (think vagina dentata meets Little Shop of Horrors) which should have run for years but ends its run next week. It would be a great fit for Southwark Playhouse, just saying… Then there were few things I laughed at as much as at the Chicago Shakespeare Theatre’s world premiere of Rob Ulin’s sit-comy but fabulous Judgement Day with Jason Alexander as an amoral lawyer trying to mend his ways to avoid eternal damnation and finding that doing good is a lot more powerful than he expected. It was an absolute treat and, like Alexander’s gleeful creation, thoroughly deserves a further life.

    So that was a lot of what I loved this year, but here’s my top twenty of 2024, in alphabetical but not necessarily preferential order….

    *

    1 AN ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE – Duke of York’s, London – closed 13 April

    Photograph by Manuel Harlan

    Less a revival than a full scale reinvigoration, this thrilling European adaptation, starring Matt Smith for London, brought Ibsen’s climate crisis tragedy worryingly up-to-date.

    *

    2 BETWEEN RIVERSIDE AND CRAZY – Hampstead, London – ended 15 June

    Photograph by Johan Persson

    Stephen Adly Gurgis’s magnificently grimy yet magical Manhattan family tragicomedy received an overdue but rambunctiously enjoyable UK premiere.

    *

    3 BRACE BRACE – Royal Court Upstairs, London – ended 9 November

    Photograph by Helen Murray

    Oli Forsyth’s taut thriller, inspired by true events, examined how humans process trauma. Daniel Raggett’s hyper-focused staging featured terrific acting and a hair-raising approximation of a plane crash.

    *

    4 CABLE STREET – Southwark Playhouse, London – ended 10 October

    Photograph by Jane Hobson

    I doubt we’ve seen the last of this exciting British musical that played two sold out seasons. Retelling the story of the 1936 Battle of Cable Street where multicultural East Enders joined forces to defeat the fascists, it’s London’s own Les Mis.

    *

    5 CYRANO – Park, London – playing NOW until 11 January 2025

    Photograph by Mihaela Bodlovic

    Already a deserved smash in Australia and Edinburgh, this anachronistic queer riff on Rostand’s beloved text honours the original but repaints it with rainbow coloured joy for the 21st century. Writer and star Virginia Gay is the real deal.

    https://parktheatre.co.uk/event/cyrano/

    *

    6 DEATH BECOMES HER – Lunt-Fontanne, NYC – playing NOW in an open-ended run

    Photograph by Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman

    High camp done right: caught this musical adaptation of the Meryl Streep-Goldie Hawn movie in its Chicago tryout and it was already fabulous but it’s been gloriously fine-tuned for Broadway. Megan Hilty and Jennifer Simard are gorgeous, glamorous…and deadly.

    https://deathbecomesher.com

    *

    7 FIDDLER ON THE ROOF – Regents Park Open Air, London – ended 28 September

    Photograph by Marc Brenner

    Jordan Fein’s soul-stirring revival of the Broadway classic was that unique thing: a supremely intelligent and moving take on a familiar show that gave traditionalists everything they needed but still provided fresh insights.

    *

    8 GIANT – Royal Court, London – ended 16 November : reopens Apollo, London 26 April 2025

    Photograph by Manuel Harlan

    Mark Rosenblatt’s brilliant debut put the artistry and the antisemitism of literary titan Roald Dahl under the microscope. It feels like an instant modern classic elevated even higher by John Lithgow and a peerless cast.

    https://gianttheplay.com

    *

    9 HELLS KITCHEN – Shubert, NYC – playing NOW in an open-ended run

    Photograph by Marc J Franklin

    Simultaneously a thunderous Valentine to one of Manhattan’s most vibrant quarters and a jubilant celebration of Alicia Keys’s history and back catalogue, this is so exhilarating it’s practically an out-of-body experience.

    https://hellskitchen.com

    *

    10 JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR – Delamar, Amsterdam, Netherlands and touring – ended 17 November

    Photograph by Jan Versweyveld

    Ivo van Hove’s gritty, blood soaked Jesus Christ Superstar (with not a single camera or video screen in sight!) in the Netherlands (but performed in English), seemed less about religion than collective responsibility, and it was enthralling.

    *

    11 KING LEAR – Almeida, London – ended 30 March

    Photograph by Marc Brenner

    Danny Sapani was an astounding Lear in a Yael Farber production that was an object lesson in how to update and recontextualise Shakespeare without sacrificing urgency, clarity or poetry.

    *

    12 NATASHA, PIERRE & THE GREAT COMET OF 1812 – Donmar, London – playing NOW until 8 February 2025

    Photograph by Manuel Harlan

    It’s sold out but keep trying for returns for this intoxicating American musical culled from a section of War And Peace, given a marvellously chic and eccentric staging by the Donmar’s new AD Tim Sheader.

    https://www.donmarwarehouse.com/whats-on/35/music-lyrics-book-orchestrations-by-dave-malloy/natasha-pierre-the-great-comet-of-1812

    *

    13 OH, MARY! – Lyceum, NYC – playing NOW until 28 June 2025

    Photograph by Emilio Madrid

    The off-Broadway show that could! Who knew that a stage life of deeply unhappy First Lady Mary Todd Lincoln could be this much fun. Oh, Mary! has rightly catapulted writer and star Cole Escola to mainstream stardom. An absolute riot.

    https://www.ohmaryplay.com

    *

    14 SHIFTERS – Bush, London then Duke of York’s, London – ended 12 October

    Photograph by Craig Fuller

    Benedict Lombe’s heart meltingly beautiful love song cum memory play moved around in time but never confusingly. Heather Agyepong and Tosin Cole burned bright in Lynette Linton’s generous, supple staging.

    *

    15 STEREOPHONIC – John Golden, NYC – playing NOW until 12 January 2025

    Photograph by Julieta Cervantes

    Another instant classic, but this time on the other side of the Pond (though allegedly headed to London in 2025). David Adjmi’s remarkable dissection of a rock band recording an iconic album is like the most riveting fly-on-the-wall documentary.

    https://stereophonicplay.com

    *

    16 THE CABINET MINISTER – Menier Chocolate Factory, London – ended 16 November

    Photograph by Tristram Kenton

    With her barnstorming central turn in this triumphant Pinero reclamation, Nancy Carroll reconfirmed her position as heiress apparent to the high comedy mantle of Dame Maggie Smith. She also did the naughty but nice adaptation and Paul Foster helmed a production that felt simultaneously timely and sparklingly escapist.

    *

    17 THE FEAR OF 13 – Donmar Warehouse, London – ended 30 November

    Photograph by Manuel Harlan

    Oscar winner Adrien Brody made a coruscating stage bow in Lindsey Ferrentino’s riveting true life tale of injustice and wrongful imprisonment, given a cracking staging by Justin Martin featuring another incandescent debut from Nana Mensah.

    *

    18 THE OUTSIDERS – Bernard B Jacobs, NYC – playing NOW in an open-ended run

    Photograph by Matthew Murphy

    Winner of this years Best Musical Tony award, this adaptation of S E Hinton’s beloved novel is a real beauty. A dark but uplifting coming-of- age tale set in late 1960s Oklahoma, the score is bluesily haunting and Dayna Taylor’s staging stuns.

    https://outsidersmusical.com

    *

    19 THE PRODUCERS – Menier Chocolate Factory, London – playing NOW until 1 March 2025

    Photograph by Manuel Harlan

    Director Patrick Marber and choreographer Lorin Latarro may be delivering a scaled down version of Mel Brooks’s anarchic tuner but it’s every bit as wonderful as Susan Stroman’s original extravaganza.

    https://www.menierchocolatefactory.com

    *

    20 TILL THE STARS COME DOWN – National Theatre/Dorfman, London – ended 16 March

    Photograph by Manuel Harlan

    Beth Steel’s engrossing, hilarious play combined warring sisters, the state of the nation and a wedding from hell to tumultuous, unforgettable effect. The writing, the performances, the staging…all exemplary. A gem.

    December 26, 2024

  • CYRANO – ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Rostand reimagined, and it’s an absolute blast of joy and feeling

    Virginia Gay and Joseph Evans, photograph by Craig Sugden

    CYRANO

    by Virginia Gay, after Edmond Rostand

    directed by Clare Watson 

    Park Theatre, London – until 11 January 2025

    https://parktheatre.co.uk/event/cyrano/

    Edmond Rostand’s big-nosed, poetry spouting swashbuckler gets a gay, feminist makeover in this delightful update, and it’s one of the most life-enhancing things on any current London stage. Author and star (although Cyrano is very much an ensemble piece), Australian multi-hyphenate Virginia Gay takes Rostand’s beloved, but increasingly problematic, tale and drags it, not so much kicking and screaming as giggling and winking, into the 21st century, with illuminating results.

    Refocusing Cyrano, the scholar, bon viveur and wit, always “the most interesting person in the room”, as a high achieving, slightly intimidating, queer outsider makes perfect sense. This Cyrano is popular and charismatic, but she feels like an observer, a bystander, watching other people’s lives but not fully participating in her own by dint, she thinks, of her facial abnormality: as with the acclaimed Jamie Lloyd-James McAvoy modernisation a few years ago, there’s no prosthetic nose, just plenty of textual reminders.

    Gay’s Cyrano is irresistibly funny and warm, but the vein of melancholy running through her is keenly felt, as is the sudden, shocking aggression that comes to the fore in moments of conflict or sheer frustration at the idiocy of her intellectual inferiors (Tanvir Virmani’s adorably kookie chorus member is a regular recipient of her ire). Gay’s is a complex, psychologically acute portrayal that honours Rostand’s original creation while making this Cyrano very much her own woman. Crucially, we care about her very much right from the beginning.

    Equally her own woman is Jessica Whitehurst’s terrific Roxanne. Far from the cosseted princess of Rostand’s Cyrano de Bergerac, she is a sexy, self aware, feisty young woman who’s kind but doesn’t suffer fools gladly. It’s all too easy to see why Cyrano and Christian, the soldier whose flawless exterior doesn’t match the apparent command of poetic language that makes Roxanne weak at the knees, fall for her.

    Yan – short for Christian – is played as a muscular, bluntly spoken Mancunian, more brawn than brains, but not without sensitivity. Joseph Evans renders his cluelessness surprisingly charming, and makes something really touching out of the realisation that Roxanne will never love his authentic self as much as he wants and needs her to. 

    The choric trio that sets the scene and comments on the action, and on the choices of the principal characters, is another source of joy. Virmani’s gauche youngster, rampantly hot for Yan and unable to remember her own name when challenged, Tessa Wong’s cute bossyboots and David Tarkenter’s world weary old stager, all have shining comic moments and make a wonderfully mismatched team.

    To house this freewheeling, consistently enchanting riff on a classic, Gay and director Clare Watson have created a slightly unhinged, supremely theatrical world, one where the improbable just keeps happening. It’s a milieu where the austerity of a bare stage transforms into a hedonistic dancefloor in the blink of an eye, where the company gathered around a battered old piano unexpectedly breaks into exquisite multiple part harmony versions of pop songs, where an apparently buttoned-up cast member suddenly and hilariously starts expressing himself via interpretive dance, and where the entire audience find themselves as party guests, decked out with streamers and paper hats, while glitter falls from the flies. The sense of goodwill and lunatic magic makes the genuinely dramatic moments fall into sharp, potent relief. This is a play and production that satisfies on every level.

    That’s especially true of the central plot development where Cyrano and Christian effectively gaslight Roxanne into falling for the latter. It may have felt romantic and noble in Rostand’s day but it doesn’t play so well in the age of #MeToo. Whitehurst’s fury and disappointment when she discovers the duplicity is authentically powerful. When one of the chorus asks what happens next, Gay’s Cyrano, with a combination of sullenness and shame, mutters “I die so she has to forgive me”. Mercifully that’s not the fate of this poetic dreamer and a tragedy is turned into a celebration of self realisation and forgiveness.

    Gay’s script is a wondrous thing, riotously funny when it seeks to be but emotionally deft. It’s also tremendously erotic. With the highly amusing interjections from the chorus, this Cyrano is as much an examination of the nature of theatrical storytelling as it is a reinvention of the beloved romantic classic. 

    Watson’s intimate staging, a smash hit at the Edinburgh Festival this year and it’s easy to see why, is bold and inventive, slick enough for us to know we’re in the hands of real artists but rough-around-the-edges enough to ensure moments of real surprise, and it moves at a cracking pace. Andy Purves’s mood-shifting lighting, Toby Young’s sound, Amanda Stoodley’s unfussy designs and Paul Herbert’s glorious musical direction all combine with staging and performances to create the impression of that rare, exhilarating theatrical beast where everyone involved is singing from the same joyous hymn-sheet.

    The ninety magical minutes fly by, you’ll laugh a lot, maybe cry a little, and emerge uplifted with a fresh perspective on a well known story and unequivocally fall in love with this cast. As much as a love story and a queer affirmation, it’s an exhortation to grab life by the balls. At the conclusion, I had tears in my eyes and couldn’t wipe the soppy grin off my face: I simply cannot recommend this highly enough.

     

    December 22, 2024

  • THE INVENTION OF LOVE – ⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Simon Russell Beale and a fine cast shine in challenging Stoppard revival

    Dickie Beau and Simon Russell Beale, photograph by Helen Murray

    THE INVENTION OF LOVE

    by Tom Stoppard

    directed by Blanche McIntyre

    Hampstead Theatre, London – until 1 February 2024

    https://www.hampsteadtheatre.com/whats-on/2024/the-invention-of-love/

    When theatregoers refer to Stoppard as intimidatingly clever, it’s plays like this 1997 meditation on poetry, classicism and the regrets of a life not fully lived that helped cement that reputation. Really though, The Invention of Love is about, well, love; love in its purest form. It’s dressed up with Stoppard’s customary verbal dexterity and mind-bogglingly detailed background research and knowledge, but it’s hard to miss the beating, broken heart at its core.

    Simon Russell Beale plays scholar and poet A E Housman, first seen after his death in 1936, being ferried across the River Styx into the afterlife (“I’m dead, then. Good. And this is the Stygian gloom one has heard so much about”) by a wry Charon (Alan Williams, very funny). Instead of eternity though, Housman is transported back to a vision of his younger self (a wonderfully gauche and earnest Matthew Tennyson) and his contemporaries at Oxford University in the mid nineteenth century. While the academics debate the High Victorianism in literature, art and morality versus the Aesthetic movement, prizing beauty over function and spearheaded by Dickie Beau’s flamboyant, whip-smart Oscar Wilde, youthful Housman is equally preoccupied with his covert, unrequited love for an athletic fellow student.

    Stoppard’s cerebral script is peppered with aphorisms, literary quotes and Latin, and Blanche McIntyre’s chilly staging zips it along at as spritely a pace as possible but ultimately can’t, or possibly isn’t interested in, disguising the fact that this is a pretty static piece, characterised mostly by men talking. That’s not the only way in which it feels defiantly unfashionable: for starters, there’s the length (three hours including interval); then the fact that, for all the youth of many of the principal figures and the forbidden carnal urges represented, the play remains determinedly unsexy.

    It is however a feast of fine acting. Tennyson breaks down most affectingly when confessing his love for Ben Lloyd-Hughes’s bewildered, likeable, sporty Jackson. A superb trio of actors – Jonnie Broadbent, Stephen Boxer and Dominic Rowan –  brilliantly differentiate between a series of wittily pontificating literary and academic figures. Dickie Beau’s Oscar Wilde is a brittle, volatile creation (“better a fallen rocket than never a burst of light”), supremely stylish but with a hint of real anguish, and his scene with a rueful Housman, bringing the contrasts between their very different approaches to their (at the time) illegal sexuality, into sharp, unforgiving relief, is the most engrossing and moving in the play.

    Few, if any, actors are as adept as Simon Russell Beale at conveying roiling feeling under a facade of unimpeachable urbanity and ferocious intelligence, tempered with irresistible sweetness and humour. He’s in his element here, as a sympathetic, all too human Housman. As with his triumphant, Tony-nominated turn in the same author’s Jumpers as the emotionally stunted philosopher whose marriage is imploding, he gives us a fully realised intellectual who we can see and feel thinking….and suffering. It’s a beautiful performance.

    McIntyre’s production falls between the impressionistic and the overly literal: men play billiards in a rectangular slice of light, small set pieces fuse together to make boats drifting down the Cherwell (or is it the Thames…or the Styx?!), party streamers and a half populated tea table descend for the Oscar Wilde section, benches on green banks judder clumsily into view. I think the idea is that these are fragments of memory in the minds eye, but the lack of flow and enchantment in McIntyre’s staging and Morgan Large’s generally uninspired design (dimly lit by Peter Mumford) means that it sometimes feels frustratingly unfocused. Richard Eyre’s original National Theatre production had a painterly quality, and a degree of that aesthetic pleasure wouldn’t go amiss here.

    This is very much a night ‘on’, and it clearly won’t be for everybody but watching actors of the calibre of Beale and his cast mates is always a pleasure. Stoppard’s writing has an elegant ferocity, butn the theatricality that adds an irresistible tang  to much of the rest of his esteemed canon is mostly missing here. The emotional undertow is there though…you just have to work to get at it.

    December 20, 2024

  • CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF – ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Rebecca Frecknall returns to Tennessee Williams in this striking rethink of a volatile classic

    Daisy Edgar-Jones and Kingsley Ben-Adir, photograph by Marc Brenner

    CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF

    by Tennessee Williams

    directed by Rebecca Frecknall

    Almeida Theatre, London – until 1 February 2025

    https://almeida.co.uk/whats-on/cat-on-a-hot-tin-roof/

    This surprising, affecting Cat On A Hot Tin Roof is the apotheosis of Rebecca Frecknall’s deconstructed Tennessee Williams trilogy for the Almeida. Where her 2018 Summer And Smoke elevated a B-grade play to something profound and moving, and the Paul Mezcal-Patsy Ferran Streetcar (returning briefly to the West End in 2025 before heading to NYC) found a humanity beneath the archetypes of Stanley and Blanche, this Cat refocuses the relationships in a play that, although written with Williams’s characteristic bruised poeticism, can sometimes feel excessively precious and long winded. 

    True to form, Frecknall goes for style and expressionism over the cooking heat that usually typifies this play. Some of it’s a bit heavy handed (having Daisy Edgar-Jones’s Maggie the cat crawling about like a real feline scores few points for subtlety) but this is an infinitely more satisfying version than the last London production in 2017 which saw Jack O’Connell and Sienna Miller as its photogenic Brick and Maggie wandering around naked on a bizarre, copper-coloured set that rendered more than half of the dialogue inaudible.

    The first act is essentially a monologue for Maggie as she berates, cajoles and tries to get through to her increasingly catatonic husband, tortured former sports star Brick, while his plantation owner father’s birthday party is in full swing throughout the house outside their bedroom. I’ve seen it defeat more seasoned stage actresses than Edgar-Jones but she acquits herself magnificently here, even though she seems a little youthful. With her flashing dark eyes and auburn mane, red talons and sheer slip, she looks like a debauched version of Anne Hathaway (the film star), and she captures with graceful precision and piercing emotional acuity Maggie’s mix of sensuousness, anxiety and desperation. There’s a compelling vulnerability too: note the way she sucks her breath back in almost before it has left her body. She knows she has lost Brick already but is too self possessed to admit defeat.

    Frecknall has the words delivered against the steady tick-tock of the metronome sitting atop the grand piano that dominates Chloe Lamford’s austere set. It’s a hypnotic effect that lulls us into a false sense of peace before the piano keyboard takes an absolute pounding at moments of high stress and conflict. Frecknall’s earlier Williams stagings employed music in a similar way. 

    She also reuses the convention of having a named but usually unseen character as a constant onstage presence. Personally, I thought having Skipper (a magnetic Seb Carrington), Brick’s best buddy (and something more) who drank himself to death, close to the centre of the action, playing piano, observing the marital tussles of the central couple, and getting progressively more soused, was the most potent example yet of this storytelling device. There’s a moment in the second half when Kingsley Ben-Adir’s Brick, drunk, in deep despair and cowering from yet another volley of recriminations, sinks down onto the piano stool and Skipper tenderly puts his arms around him. It’s a heart-piercing image that’s worth a thousand words, even when the words are as beautiful as Tennessee’s.

    Good as Edgar-Jones is, this production decentralises Maggie to the extent that after the first act she effectively becomes just another bystander to Brick’s ongoing dance of death with the bottle and his beloved, lost Skipper. I have never seen a more moving or dangerous Brick than Ben-Adir. Out of his mind and on a clear course to self-destruction from the get-go, his torment and misery writ large across his features, he also conveys with devastating clarity the character’s detachment and his casual cruelty. He’s pitiful but you can’t take your eyes off him.

    The centrepiece, arguably of the somewhat unwieldy script but undoubtedly of this production, is the electrifying showdown between Brick and his father. Usually a feast of grandstanding and recriminations, here it’s repurposed as a much more sensitive exchange, charged with implicit understanding (look out for the brief but astonishing moment when Big Daddy talks about tolerance). Lennie James is utterly brilliant as a man able to turn on a dime between kindness and cruelty. James makes obvious but never overplays the cancer eating him up from the inside and to which he is oblivious, and his irascible disrespect towards his long-suffering vulgarian wife (a strangely sympathetic Clare Burt, absolutely terrific) is superbly done. 

    This isn’t colour blind casting either: this wealthy black man has worked his way up from the lowliest positions in the plantation to being master of all he surveys, and it results in a more compassionate and multi-layered reading of the role than usual, and James is turning in a truly great performance. There’s magnificent support too from Ukweli Roach as the feckless, overlooked other son, Pearl Chanda as his envious, endlessly fertile wife (here given an intriguingly ambiguous attitude towards the more glamorous Maggie) and Guy Burgess as a hilariously fey local preacher.

    Hugely watchable as this is, and at times it is completely riveting, I do think Frecknall has reached the end of the road with Williams and his ghosts. I also don’t think I’ll ever see a finer Brick and Big Daddy than Ben-Adir and James. Nor will I be able to forget the look on Burt’s face when she learns the truth about her husband’s health.

    The three hours pretty much fly by and it all holds together: it’s just not necessarily the Cat On A Hot Tin Roof that we all thought that we knew.

    December 19, 2024

  • NATASHA, PIERRE AND THE GREAT COMET OF 1812 – ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – yes it was absolutely worth the wait

    Declan Bennett and company, photograph by Johan Persson

    NATASHA, PIERRE AND THE GREAT COMET OF 1812

    Music, lyrics and book by Dave Malloy

    directed by Tim Sheader 

    Donmar Warehouse, London – until 8 February 2025

    https://www.donmarwarehouse.com/whats-on/35/music-lyrics-book-orchestrations-by-dave-malloy/natasha-pierre-the-great-comet-of-1812

    “Gonna have to study up a little bit / If you wanna keep with the plot / Cause it’s a complicated Russian novel” trills the ensemble at the top of this eccentric musical distillation of a seventy page tranche of Tolstoy’s War And Peace, receiving its long-awaited UK premiere seven years after closing on Broadway. Actually, Dave Malloy’s quirky, intoxicating fusion of punchy electropop and lush, full blown romanticism, structurally nearer to a cantata than a traditional musical, is certainly challenging but it’s seldom hard to follow.

    It’s also rollicking good fun, not perhaps words one might expect to use when describing a Tolstoy adaptation, but here we are and here it is. Perhaps because Malloy is responsible for book, music and lyrics, there is a remarkable clarity of vision, fully realised in Tim Sheader’s modern dress staging which is equal parts grunge and glamour, so that however bizarre or random individual moments of this through-sung tuner are, there’s never a moment where you feel like anybody on, or connected to, the stage doesn’t know exactly what their brief is and how to fulfil it. It’s messy but my God it’s beautiful.

    I suspect original director Rachel Chavkin (best known in the UK for helming Hadestown) was majorly instrumental in shaping Natasha, Pierre and The Great Comet of 1812 as a piece as it moved from its beginnings way off Broadway to its Main Stem run. It breaks so many musical theatre rules – the storytelling is more scattershot than linear, characters declaim and talk about themselves in the third person, the tone veers wildly from camp to sentimental to quietly contemplative – yet it is undeniably its own haunting, ingenious thing. 

    On Broadway they turned the appropriately named Imperial Theatre into a fully immersive rendering of Moscow old and new from the moment you entered the lobby, all without compromising the show’s essential “downtown” vibe. If that version maintained its shabby-chic credentials, Sheader and designers Leslie Travers (set) and Evie Gurney (costumes) reconceive 19th century Russia for the Donmar as something like present day Shoreditch and Hoxton. It works a treat: the aesthetic is hipsterish, a little dangerous, pretty queer and entirely compelling. Brutalist lettering hangs in the sky, lush red drapes transport us from drawing room to opera house, ne’er-do-wells disport on outsized moveable packing cases, a giant, stage-dominating illuminated ring rises and falls imprisoning then freeing inhabitants, snow falls, batteries of lights whirr galvanically or hypnotically. It’s sensory overload masquerading as theatre, and it’s irresistible.

    Malloy takes Tolstoy’s sliver of a story about young Countess Natasha (a radiant Chumisa Dornford-May, fielding a voice of infinite range and colours, and given more agency then her New York predecessors) arriving in Moscow from the country to meet her betrothed who’s still away at war and falling under the spell of womanising dandy Anatole (Jamie Muscato, all tight trousers, smoky eye make up and confident screlting) and gives it several jolts of anachronistic electricity. Musically there are elements of folk, funk, atonal modern, straight classical…, and the lyrics are bright, witty and occasionally breathtaking in their open-hearted sincerity. I doubt there’s any modern musical theatre song more delicate and beautiful than ‘No One Else’, Natasha’s rapturous contemplation of youthful love, performed here atop a larger than life pink teddy bear. Surely there are few as down-and-dirty as conniving, corrupting Hélène’s funk-driven semi-seduction ‘Charming’ (“Now a woman with a dress / Is a frightening and powerful thing / You are not a child / You’re draped in scarlet and lace”) delivered with charismatic relish by a darkly magnetic Cat Simmons. The music never stops, creating a heady, lilting, sometimes sinister, often exhilarating tapestry of sound that doesn’t invite comparison with anything else in the musical theatre canon. 

    Simmons would be a show stealer if the rest of the company wasn’t so excellent. But Chloe Saracco’s icy but insecure princess, Cedric Neal’s hedonistic leather queen coachman, Daniel Krikler as Anatole’s sexy-as-hell assassin sidekick, Eugene McCoy as a grotesque elder dignitary and Annette McLaughlin’s Chanel-suited, martini dry socialite aunt all feel utterly indispensable and vivid. Then there’s Maimuna Memon as Sonya Rostova, Natasha’s staunch, smart cousin. It’s an unshowy role but Memon invests her with pin-sharp precision and makes something utterly devastating of her second act solo where Sonya resolves to stand by our wayward heroine. As unhappy, drunken Pierre, Declan Bennett delivers lovely, sensitive work and navigates the role’s rangy vocal demands superbly, although the constant references to the character’s physical size don’t make much sense. 

    Ultimately, Natasha, Pierre and The Great Comet of 1812 is that rare thing: a wildly imaginative and prodigiously talented work that is as smart as it’s original. It has antescendents in Brecht and Sondheim but even that as a description doesn’t quite prepare you for what this is. Sheader and team (also including Howard Hudson, responsible for the shapeshifting lighting and Ellen Kane whose unfettered choreography is frequently thrilling) make a very persuasive case for it as the most exciting American tuner of its generation. Musical theatre doesn’t get cooler or sexier than this. Magical.

    December 19, 2024

  • THE MASSIVE TRAGEDY OF MADAME BOVARY – ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Flaubert’s s glum tale reconceived as a fun-filled romp….and it works!

    Georgia Nicholson and Ben Kernow, photograph by Tanya Pabaru

    THE MASSIVE TRAGEDY OF MADAME BOVARY

    by John Nicholson 

    directed by Kirstie Davis 

    Southwark Playhouse – Borough, London – until 11 January 2025

    https://southwarkplayhouse.co.uk/productions/the-massive-tragedy-of-madame-bovary/

    If you’re looking for some festive escapist fun but don’t want songs and constant references to the season, get yourself to Southwark where this smart, cute riff on a challenging literary classic is a remarkable case of having its proverbial cake and eating it. John Nicholson’s script is a comic send up of Madame Bovary, Gustave Flaubert’s seminal realist novel, boiled down to just over two hours playing time and a cast of four, while also giving a clear, concise account of the plot and paying homage to the beauty of the words and ultimately the tragedy at the story’s core. That’s quite an achievement. That The Massive Tragedy of Madame Bovary, as it’s hyperbolically rechristened for the stage, is so much fun as well is real cause for rejoicing, Christmas or not.

    The downbeat, not to say downright depressing, story of the rural doctor’s wife whose dissatisfaction at her mediocre lot in life and passionless marriage drives her to infidelity, debt and ultimately suicide (these aren’t really spoilers, the book has been around since 1857…what do you mean you haven’t read it?!) is played mostly, but not entirely, for laughs. The horsing around very occasionally gets a bit tiresome, and not every gag lands, but there are moments of strange beauty in Kirstie Davis’s production that provide welcome and affecting respite.

    The jokey tone and execution of the staging, played out on Marion Harrison’s simple but evocative set of shutters, crates and drapes, is similar to that of Patrick Barlow and Maria Aitken’s long-running take on The 39 Steps. There’s dexterous multi-roling (one of the actors, Stephen Cavanagh, has fifteen roles to get through per performance), a rubber toy rat is hurled across the stage to indicate a vermin infestation in a rural French town, a seduction scene turns into a display of sleight-of-hand magic with bunches of flowers being pulled from under a voluminous skirt and rainbow streamers being dragged at length from a heaving cleavage, a blood-letting medical procedure becomes a fountain of Grand Guignol hysteria and excess. If you don’t find that sort of thing funny then you may find this show a bit of a trialn, but it has an innate bonkers-ness and charm that will likely prove pretty irresistible to everybody else. 

    Author Nicholson and director Davis make little attempt to contextualise Flaubert’s novel (although there is an audience show-of-hands survey at the beginning to ascertain how many people in the house have actually read it!) or to analyse its importance in the literary canon, presenting it instead as a jolly romp, with lots of rough magic and direct address. That the tragic elements still seep through is pretty impressive and help transform a fun evening into a satisfying one. 

    Georgia Nicholson’s Emma Bovary is a particularly striking creation, fully in tune with the less-than-serious approach of the production but also sketching with some sensitivity and conviction the crippling ennui and depression, as well as the voracious sexuality, that makes the novel’s titular character so compelling and divisive. The other three actors –  Cavanagh, Ben Kernow and Darren Seed – switch roles with dexterity, fizzing energy and good humour. If some of the physical comedy lacks precision, it adds to the overall hurl-everything-at-the-wall jollity, although the timing between bits of mimed physical business and Dan Bottomley’s vivid sound design is impressive. 

    It’s just a thoroughly agreeable time in the theatre, one that pokes gentle fun at an iconic piece of literature while maintaining a strong degree of affection for it. Irrepressibly theatrical and buoyantly funny, this is required viewing for Mischief Theatre enthusiasts and lovers of superior spoof. 

    December 16, 2024

Previous Page Next Page

Blog at WordPress.com.

 

Loading Comments...
 

    • Subscribe Subscribed
      • ajhlovestheatre
      • Join 59 other subscribers
      • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
      • ajhlovestheatre
      • Subscribe Subscribed
      • Sign up
      • Log in
      • Report this content
      • View site in Reader
      • Manage subscriptions
      • Collapse this bar